Earth Science News
FROTH AND BUBBLE
Brazil mine disaster trial ends with claimants hopeful of justice
Brazil mine disaster trial ends with claimants hopeful of justice
By Olivier Devos
London (AFP) Mar 13, 2025

A trial to decide Australian mining giant BHP's liability for one of Brazil's worst environmental disasters concluded in London on Thursday, with hundreds of thousands of victims demanding billions in compensation.

The 2015 dam collapse killed 19 people and unleashed a deluge of thick toxic mud into villages, fields, rainforest, rivers and the ocean.

The Fundao tailings dam at an iron ore mine in the mountains of Minas Gerais state was managed by Samarco, co-owned by BHP and Brazilian miner Vale.

"I will produce a judgment as soon as I can," said judge Finola O'Farrell as she announced the end of the trial.

The London High Court hearing, which began in October, heard evidence on behalf of BHP and hundreds of thousands of claimants in relation to the dam collapse that may trigger a payout worth billions of pounds (dollars).

At the time of the disaster, BHP had global headquarters in Britain and Australia.

Should the court find BHP liable, a further trial would be held to determine the amount of compensation.

- Awaiting verdict -

"I'm hoping (for a judgment) towards the end of the second quarter, perhaps in June or July this year," said Tom Goodhead, of law firm Pogust Goodhead, which brought the case.

"And then there's another trial... which has been scheduled for October 2026 in the event that it's necessary to prove the damages that people have suffered," he told AFP.

Goodhead added that for the victims, "accountability" was even more important than money.

A separate case in Brazil has seen Vale and BHP offer to pay around $30 billion in compensation.

This was increased from almost $25 billion at around the start of the London trial.

"We respect the London process," said Fernanda Lavarello, head of corporate affairs at BHP Brazil.

"We continue to defend ourselves here (in London), but we think that Brazil is the right place for us to address all these outstanding issues," she told AFP.

More than 620,000 complainants -- including 46 Brazilian local authorities, companies and Indigenous peoples -- are seeking an estimated GBP 36 billion ($47 billion) in damages in the civil trial.

BHP, while acknowledging that a "tragedy" occurred, argues that it cannot be deemed to be the "direct polluter", as the dam was managed by Samarco.

- 'Hopeful of justice' -

The dam collapse in the town of Mariana unleashed almost 45 million cubic metres (1,590 million cubic feet) of highly toxic mining waste sludge, flooding 39 towns and leaving more than 600 people homeless.

"I'm here for justice," Pamela Fernandes, who lost her five-year old daughter Manu in the tragedy, told AFP outside court.

"I will feel relief when I hear that the company will pay for what it did."

According to the victims' lawyers, BHP was aware that the accumulation of toxic sludge, estimated at 1.3 million tonnes per year, far exceeded the annual limit set -- a build-up which they say contributed to the disaster.

BHP and Vale estimate that more than 430,000 complainants have already received compensation, including more than 200,000 party to the London case.

Attending the hearing's final day was Mariana's mayor, Juliano Duarte.

"Today we came to follow the final part of the trial... seeking justice for the city of Mariana, since it was the city most affected by the dam collapse," he said.

"We hope to have better justice in London, to receive amounts commensurate with the scale of the tragedy."

BHP has noted that the Renova Foundation -- which manages compensation and rehabilitation programmes, funded by BHP, Vale and Samarco -- has paid out more than $7.9 billion in emergency aid.

The Australian mining giant has also said the quality of water in the river system contaminated by the fallout has returned to pre-disaster levels.

Related Links
Our Polluted World and Cleaning It Up

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
FROTH AND BUBBLE
London trial on 2015 Brazil mine disaster wraps up
London (AFP) Mar 13, 2025
A trial on whether Australian mining giant BHP is liable for one of Brazil's worst environmental disasters concludes Thursday in London, with hundreds of thousands of victims demanding billions in compensation. The 2015 dam collapse killed 19 people and unleashed a deluge of thick toxic mud into villages, fields, rainforest, rivers and the ocean. The Fundao tailings dam at an iron ore mine in the mountains of Minas Gerais state was managed by Samarco, co-owned by BHP and Brazilian miner Vale. ... read more

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Indonesia passes bill allowing military in more govt roles

Milei pledges funds for deluge-stricken Argentine city

UK makes manslaughter arrest of ship captain over North Sea crash

US to deploy 600 additional troops to southern border

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Young Chinese women find virtual love in 'Deepspace'

New platform lets anyone rapidly prototype large, sturdy interactive structures

Eco-friendly rare earth element separation: A bioinspired solution to an industry challenge

Historic fantasy 'Assassin's Creed' sparks bitter battles

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Take 'precautionary approach' on deep-sea mining: top official tells AFP

Planetary Water Limits Pose Challenge to Geological Resource Production

In poor areas of Peru's capital, running water is a dream

Talks on divisive deep-sea mining resume in Jamaica

FROTH AND BUBBLE
AI reveals new insights into Antarctic ice flow

Scientists aim to uncover cause of unexpected warmth in Everest glacier

Intense Atmospheric Rivers Can Partially Replenish Greenland Ice Sheet Loss

Scientists establish link between Earth's orbital shifts and ice age cycles

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Canada canola farmers squeezed by trade wars on two fronts

Dramatic increase in research funding needed to counter productivity slowdown in farming

EU countries back looser rules for gene-edited crops

Enhancing agrivoltaic synergies through optimized tracking strategies

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Florence averts disaster thanks to key floodgate

Toll from US weekend tornadoes rises to at least 40

Mozambique cyclone cluster raises fears of new norm

Quake damages buildings, sparks panic in Italy's Naples

FROTH AND BUBBLE
Sudan army makes gains as battle for Khartoum intensifies

Sudan paramilitary shelling kills six in key city: medic

S.Sudan carries out air strike against civilians: local official

EU, South Africa leaders vow deeper ties amid US threats

FROTH AND BUBBLE
When did human language emerge?

Study reveals how rising temperatures could lead to population crashes

Earliest evidence of human habitation in rainforests uncovered

Pentagon orders removal of pro-diversity online content

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.