. Earth Science News .
Doubts over thermal scanners in swine flu fight

by Staff Writers
Hong Kong (AFP) April 30, 2009
Airports across the world have rushed to install thermal scanners in an effort to halt the spread of swine flu, but experts are raising doubts about the technology's ability to spot infections.

Indonesia, Cambodia, Singapore and Australia are among the countries that have introduced or stepped up the use of the scanners in the past few days after warnings that the flu could cause a global pandemic.

United States officials have faced criticism that they are not using more thermal imaging devices, which have become a familiar sight for travellers through Asia since the outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) in 2003.

Hong Kong, which was one of the hardest hit by SARS, has thermal cameras pointed at visitors entering the southern Chinese city by land, sea or air.

Swine flu is believed to have killed as many as 84 people in Mexico -- eight of them confirmed -- and already spread to the United States, Europe, Israel and New Zealand, and governments are desperate to stop the virus spreading further.

But as the multi-coloured screens become more common, their effectiveness is being questioned.

"If a person has been exposed or infected... the person might not be symptomatic at the airport," World Health Organisation spokesman Gregory Hartl told journalists in Geneva earlier this week.

"Border controls don't work. Screening doesn't work."

Matthew Leung, one of Hong Kong's most senior government health officials, agreed that scanners had limitations.

"I don't think any single measure can be 100 percent effective and certainly I would agree with the WHO's assessment that infra-red screening at the border cannot be completely foolproof," he said.

Leung said the scanners should only be seen as one of an array of measures that governments should take.

The cameras use thermal imaging to assess the skin temperatures of people as they pass through a checkpoint, and transform that data into a coloured image on a screen.

The machines will be set up so that when someone with a high temperature, normally above 38 degrees Celsius (100 degrees Fahrenheit), passes through the testing area, his features will be highlighted in a particular colour, often red.

Those monitoring the screen would then pull over the person for further investigation and see whether the higher temperature is because of a fever, or whether the person is just out of breath or agitated.

Despite the doubts, manufacturers are benefiting from the heightened concern.

Singapore Technologies Electronics, which sold around 200 of its Infra-red Fever Screening Systems during SARS, said it had received a "small number" of orders and some enquiries in recent days.

It said the great advantage of the 50,000-US-dollar machines was that they would measure temperatures accurately without having to delay passengers' journeys.

"It is a quick and non-intrusive system for mass screening of people from a distance of more than one metre," said Lee Fook Sun, the company's deputy president of operations.

Colum Murphy, author of "Flu Action Plan: A Business Survival Guide", said the lesson from the SARS epidemic was that governments should do everything they can to avoid panic, and scanners could help calm nerves.

"Anything that can minimise fear and help people feel more secure is advantageous," said Murphy, deputy editor of the Far Eastern Economic Review.

"And even if they only manage to uncover one case and delay a possible pandemic by a few days, then the scanners have bought governments more time."

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
Epidemics on Earth - Bird Flu, HIV/AIDS, Ebola



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Swine flu hits Asia in global march
Hong Kong (AFP) May 2, 2009
Swine flu continued its global march Saturday as South Korea confirmed its first case and Hong Kong and China scrambled to track down anybody who had been in contact with an infected Mexican man.







  • Mangroves Save Lives In Storms
  • Implementing Sustainable Technology To Monitor The Integrity Of Bridges
  • How Day-Planner For Astronauts Helps Firefighters
  • At least 30 missing in Peru mudslide

  • Severity, Length Of Past Megadroughts Dwarf Recent Drought In West Africa
  • Aerosols May Drive A Significant Portion Of Arctic Warming
  • Decline In Greenhouse Gas Emissions Would Reduce Sea-Level Rise
  • US environment agency deems CO2 a health risk

  • Satellites Show How Earth Moved During Italy Quake
  • Satnav Reflection Technology For Remote Sensing Of The Earth
  • Satellites Show Arctic Literally On Thin Ice
  • NASA Goddard Orders Second Instrument For GPM Mission

  • Analysis: China ups Kazakh energy holdings
  • Analysis: Turkish-Armenian thaw and energy
  • UC Davis Receives Renewable Energy Programs Grant
  • Analysis: Oil and Gas Pipeline Watch

  • Taiwan seeks seven passengers on Asian swine flu flight
  • DNA Barcoding Of Mosquito Species Deployed In Bid To End Elephantiasis
  • Doubts over thermal scanners in swine flu fight
  • Swine flu hits Asia in global march

  • When Industrious Ants Go Too Far
  • Did Dinosaurs Survive The End Cretaceous Extinctions
  • Rally against shark fin trade opens in Singapore
  • Feather Color Is More Than Skin Deep

  • Landfill Cover Soil Methane Oxidation Underestimated
  • Brazil: poverty, desperation at Amazon 'El dorado'
  • Pollution in Chinese cities 'extremely severe': minister
  • Sofia mayor in 'garbage war' with Bulgaria PM

  • Tiny Genetic Differences Shed Light On The Big Picture Of Human History
  • Is There A Seat Of Wisdom In The Brain
  • British woman does 314-foot ocean dive
  • Teeth Of Columbus' Crew Flesh Out Tale Of New World Discovery

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement