Earth Science News
WATER WORLD
In flooded south, Ukraine builds landmark ecocide case against Russia
In flooded south, Ukraine builds landmark ecocide case against Russia
By Florent VERGNES
Chornobaivka, Ukraine (AFP) Dec 4, 2023

Stood in the cold air of a southern Ukrainian village, dozens of investigators were digging into the ground, collecting dirt, taking photos and planting small red flags in the soil.

Watching over the proceedings was Vladislav Ignatenko, a Ukrainian prosecutor conducting a world-first war crimes investigation into allegations of Russian ecocide.

The case, which Kyiv plans to take to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in some form, is the latest in a string of investigations and challenges that Ukraine hopes will hold Russia accountable -- and make it pay -- for its invasion.

The investigation in the southern Kherson region stems from the extensive flooding caused after the Kakhovka dam was partially destroyed on June 6 in a series of early morning blasts.

Dozens were killed as entire villages became submerged and the United Nations says there was $14 billion of destruction.

Ukraine says Russia blew up the dam and that the extent of the environmental damage constitutes a war crime.

To build its case, it has dispatched a hundreds-strong team of ecological investigators.

"We're going to use every possible method to gather evidence," Ignatenko, 32, told AFP.

Donning a military t-shirt and scrawling in a notebook, he called the hundreds working on the case "pioneers."

Russia has blamed Ukraine for the dam's destruction. Both sides have denied responsibility.

It was under Russia's control and the flooding complicated Ukraine's counteroffensive in the south.

The evidence collected in the village of Chornobaivka is just a small part of Kyiv's case.

"Our next point will be here, in this district of Kherson," Ignatenko said, pointing to a map.

"I'm not going there, it's too dangerous," one of his team protested.

The city has been under constant Russian shelling since Ukraine reclaimed it in November 2022.

- Polluted soil -

In Ukraine, ecocide -- deliberately destroying the natural environment -- is a specific criminal offence.

While the Rome Statute that underpins the ICC does not recognise "ecocide" as a crime in itself, its Article Eight states that large-scale environmental damage can be considered part of a war crimes case.

But the evidential barrier is high.

It must be proven that one side carried out an attack, that it knew it would cause "long-term and severe damage to the natural environment" and that the damage was "excessive" in relation to any perceived military advantage.

Ukraine is unperturbed.

Maksym Popov, a special adviser on environmental crimes to the Ukrainian Prosecutor General, has sent more than 400 prosecutors and investigators to gather evidence and Kyiv plans to prosecute Russia both at home and internationally.

Standing next to a row of houses, Ignatenko pointed to a mark on the wall above the ground.

"The water flooded this field... After conducting an analysis, we will be able to determine whether there are traces of pesticide or hydrocarbons -- polluted soil."

Flooding washed away petrol stations and farmhouses storing pesticides, raising concerns the land is now likely contaminated.

"When the water spilled out, it picked up pollutants and dumped them on land where farm animals were being kept," Ignatenko said.

For its case to succeed, Ukraine will first need to prove Russia blew up the dam.

"That's our conviction. Another investigation is underway to that end," the prosecutor said, as he packed a sample of earth into a plastic bag bearing the Ukrainian police logo.

On May 30 -- a week before the dam exploded -- Russia adopted a law banning the investigation of incidents concerning "hydraulic structures" in parts of Ukraine it claims to have annexed.

- 'Dynamic ecosystem' -

About 300 kilometres (185 miles) upstream, on the outskirts of Zaporizhzhia, biologist Vadym Maniuk walked across dry, crunchy ground.

Beneath his feet were millions of freshwater mussel shells, scattered across the old bed of the Kakhovka reservoir.

"There used to be four metres of water here," Maniuk, an associate professor at Dnipro's Oles Honchar University, told AFP.

"Billions of living organisms were killed suddenly, in a few days," when the reservoir emptied, Maniuk said.

To him, the charges of ecocide are undeniable given the scale of the disaster.

But almost six months later, life is returning, he said.

"We have regained a dynamic ecosystem in just a few months," he said.

The ground is strewn with shells and carp skeletons -- but goats have now taken to grazing on small shrubs.

Locals ride bicycles across the former waterway, weaving between boulders.

Biologists such as Maniuk are currently in a tussle with Ukraine's energy industry over whether to rebuild the dam.

"The scientists are against it, we're fighting against the energy lobby," he said.

It generated "negligible" power and a big reconstruction project would damage the local environment once more, Maniuk argued.

"The people here have already made the area their own. For shepherds and fishermen, the conditions are better."

Related Links
Water News - Science, Technology and Politics

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
WATER WORLD
UN reports 'staggering' $14 bn cost of Ukraine dam breach
Kyiv, Ukraine (AFP) Oct 17, 2023
The destruction of the Kakhovka dam in southeastern Ukraine in June caused $14 billion worth of damage and losses, a report by the Ukrainian government and the United Nations said Tuesday. Ukraine accused Russia of blowing up the dam, which crosses the Dnipro river, flooding the surrounding area with landmine-contaminated water and leaving areas upstream without water supply. Moscow has denied responsibility. "The stark figures speak for themselves. The destruction of the Kakhovka dam has re ... read more

WATER WORLD
Three months after quake, Morocco villages face winter chill

US pledges climate aid for cities, more private sector finance

Planet tipping points pose 'unprecedented' threat to humanity: report

Aging societies more vulnerable to collapse

WATER WORLD
CityU develops universal metasurface antenna, advancing 6G communications

LeoLabs Partners with Aalyria to enhance global communication network security

Tracking undetectable space junk

York Space Systems achieves rapid start up of BANE satellite post launch

WATER WORLD
In flooded south, Ukraine builds landmark ecocide case against Russia

Philippines, France to pursue key defence pact

U.S. announces plan to boost operations with AUKUS partners in Indo-Pacific region

Study identifies key algae species helping soft corals survive warming oceans

WATER WORLD
Himalayan glaciers react, blow cold winds down their slopes

Greenland's Inuit falling through thin ice of climate change

Russia ramps up Arctic route ambitions

Antarctica's ancient ice sheets foreshadow dynamic changes in Earth's future

WATER WORLD
Morocco gardening school cultivates hope for marginalised youth

Vertically farmed greens taste as good as organic ones

Maghreb farmers embrace drones to fight climate change

Over 130 nations agree to include food, agriculture in climate plans

WATER WORLD
Two dead, 10 missing after Indonesia floods and landslide

Magnitude 5.7 quake shakes Philippine capital

Indonesia volcano search effort focuses on last missing hiker

Eight dead as cyclone batters India's southeast coast

WATER WORLD
Benin launches medals for troops as jihadists step up attacks

NGOs call for release of Burkinabe rights defender

Dozens killed after Nigerian army drone strike hits villagers

Libya dismantles illegal gold mining network

WATER WORLD
New Archaeological Discoveries Shed Light on Austronesian Migration

Fishing chimpanzees found to enjoy termites as a seasonal treat

Good neighbors: Bonobo study offers clues into early human alliances

How "blue" and "green" appeared in a language that didn't have words for them

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.