. Earth Science News .
DEMOCRACY
Outside View: Egypt and Pakistan

Top US lawmaker sees Bahrain 'concern'
Washington (AFP) Feb 16, 2011 - A top US lawmaker expressed "concern" on Wednesday about unrest in Bahrain, citing close, long-time good relations including as a base for US warships operating throughout the region. Republican Representative Todd Akin, who heads the House Armed Services subcommittee with oversight over US naval power, told AFP that "certainly we are concerned" about demonstrations demanding political change in the Gulf kingdom. "That concern, to some degree, is focused on the fact that we're not quite sure what all of these different destabilized political situations are going to mean," Akin said, amid turmoil in strategically vital places like Egypt.

"Certainly Bahrain is important to our interests, as a port. And there have been good relations that we've enjoyed with them in the past," said Akin, who represents a district in the heartland US state of Missouri. "Those are all things that cause us to want to pay close attention to what's going on," said the lawmaker, who served in the US Army as an engineer. His comments came as thousands of Bahrainis chanted for a change of regime in the pro-Western Gulf kingdom at the burial of a second protester killed in clashes with police. After the funeral, large crowds poured on to the capital Manama's Pearl Square, which demonstrators occupied on Tuesday with some erecting tents for the night like their counterparts on Cairo's Tahrir Square whose 18 straight days of protests triggered the fall of former president Hosni Mubarak.

Gates: Mideast unrest needs 'diplomatic' response
Washington (AFP) Feb 16, 2011 - Defense Secretary Robert Gates told lawmakers on Wednesday that unrest in Egypt and across the Middle East is "a diplomatic challenge" and played down any chance of sending US troops. "The kinds of instability that we're seeing in the Middle East now, it is difficult for me to imagine circumstances in which we would send US ground forces in any of those situations," he said. "It's primarily a diplomatic challenge for us," Gates told the House of Representatives' Armed Services Committee amid turmoil in Egypt, Bahrain, Libya, Iran and across the region. Gates also praised the Egyptian military's "professionalism" in that country's political crisis and called their restraint "proof of the value" of US military aid and training over the past three decades. The secretary had been asked by Republican Representative Joe Wilson whether the sometimes violent unrest in the region might "require more boots on the ground."

US top military chief warns on 'foolhardy' Egypt aid cuts
Washington (AFP) Feb 16, 2011 - The top US military officer warned lawmakers on Wednesday against making "foolhardy" cuts to military aid or assistance to countries like Egypt, amid a bitter battle over slashing government spending. "The world is a lot less predictable now than we could ever have imagined. You need look no further than Tahrir Square to see the truth in that," Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, told lawmakers. "Foolhardy would it be for us to make hasty judgments about the benefits -- tangible and intangible -- that are to be derived from forging strong military relationships overseas, such as the one we enjoy with Egypt," he said. Mullen, speaking to the US House of Representatives Armed Services Committee, bluntly told lawmakers mulling deep spending cuts to consider the "incalculable" value of close cooperation with Egypt's military amid the country's crisis. "Changes to those relationships -- in either aid or assistance -- ought to be considered only with an abundance of caution and a thorough appreciation for the long view, rather than in the flush of public passion and the urgency to save a buck," he said.
by Harlan Ullman
Washington (UPI) Feb 16, 2011
For very different reasons, extraordinary events in Egypt and Pakistan could dramatically redefine global politics.

The unanswerable first question is whether any such tectonic change, if it occurs, will be for good or for ill? A more nagging concern is given the excitement, outrage and expectations generated by these very different events, are the effects being exaggerated? Last, is time friend or foe in affecting any resolution?

In Egypt, huge public demonstrations ended the nearly 30 year rule of Hosni Mubarak. But what has changed beyond the dramatic resolve and courage displayed by many Egyptians? An 82-year-old ex-air force general has been replaced by a 75-year-old former infantry officer turned field marshal -- Mohammed Tantawi -- and a ruling defense council that declared martial law, disbanded Parliament, suspended the constitution and promised free and fair elections. To the untrained eye is this not some form of a popularly inspired coup?

Clearly, the senior Egyptian army leadership isn't anxious to run a nation with the absence of timely solutions to the economic and political crises it confronts. The government has been more or less left in place. Free and fair elections have been promised assuming a political infrastructure can be put in place over six months to include organizing political parties and identifying qualified candidates for elective office.

Yet, the public mood for more change and for speedy redress to its grievances now that Mubarak is gone cannot be understated. Unfortunately, rectifying decades of rot will take time. And time may be the one factor that any Egyptian government -- army or civilian -- doesn't have.

About Pakistan and the United States, strategic partners are at daggers drawn over Raymond Davis, the American accused by the Lahore police of killing two Pakistanis in broad daylight. The United States insists that Davis has and had diplomatic immunity. The Pakistanis disagree. And the statement by former Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi immediately after he was dropped from the Cabinet that the Foreign Office concluded Davis didn't have immunity was, at the least, unhelpful.

High-level contacts, including the trilateral meeting in Washington this month with Afghanistan and Pakistan and Pakistani President Asif Zardari's state visit, have been suspended.

With the Egyptian crisis less visible at the moment, the U.S. Congress will turn its attention to Pakistan. And, most likely, cooler heads won't prevail as the "free Davis now" movement grows. All of this suggests retaliation that will do long-term and possibly irreversible damage to both sides including making the job in Afghanistan tougher.

Can anything be done to channel the optimism triggered by the Egyptian protests into achieving a more open and more democratic society and to quench what could become an uncontrolled political firestorm in Pakistan over Davis's fate? This is where creativity and innovation are vital.

Only Egyptians can and will determine their future. One step the international community should take is to create a reservoir of capable people and resources to assist Egypt with advice and funding Egyptians need and request. Such an organization can be formed under the auspices of the United Nations or European Union and offered to a parallel organization set up and run by Egypt with Egyptian members who are persons of letters, integrity, experience and ability.

The example to avoid was the liberation of Eastern Europe post Soviet Union (or after the 2003 invasion of Iraq) when thousands of outside and often unqualified "experts" and consultants raced to fill the void with particular theologies or theories not based on the actual needs of the resident populations. Hence, as the Egyptian army and government closely examine the economic, political and structural landscape of Egypt, specific assistance under Egyptian leadership from building political parties and voting procedures to repairing the economy, education and social needs can follow.

For Pakistan, the first step must be assembling without bias or opinion, the arguments of both sides regarding diplomatic immunity. So far, the United States has been inflexible in its assertion of immunity. But, surely, given the flurry of contradictory reports that cloud this issue, mistakes were made by both countries. Comparing records and identifying errors and differences, if carefully done, can lead to satisfactory closure as it appears that at some point Davis had immunity. And transferring Davis to a fully secure location under "joint" Pakistani and U.S. custody will suggest movement and create a little breathing room in Washington.

In Egypt, we are seeing what Churchill called the "end of the beginning," not the converse. Time can be a friend or a foe. The jury is out.

In Pakistan, time isn't a friend. This situation must be resolved within days or a few weeks at most if the strategic relationship is to survive.

(Harlan Ullman is chairman of the Killowen Group, which advises leaders of government and business, and senior adviser at Washington's Atlantic Council.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)



Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
Democracy in the 21st century at TerraDaily.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


DEMOCRACY
Egypt's arms industry depends on U.S.
Cairo (UPI) Feb 15, 2011
Washington's role in arming Egypt and bolstering its defense industry over the last three decades was a key factor in defining how the country's military handled the ousting of President Hosni Mubarak earlier this month. Egypt's arms industry is the oldest, the largest and the most technologically advanced in the Arab world. The country's extensive military establishment, which has vast ... read more







DEMOCRACY
Haiti town struggles to emerge from the rubble

Australia flags taxpayer levy for floods

Haiti candidates press for more quake aid

Lucky crash escape for Honduran ministers

DEMOCRACY
Fronts shift in smartphone war with Nokia-Microsoft tie-up

US regulators examine Apple media platform: WSJ

Long lost silent movies returned to US

Champions shaping up for browser battles

DEMOCRACY
Swedish city declares its tap water 'safe'

Rising Seas Will Affect Major US Coastal Cities By 2100

Natural Power Assist The Shetland Islands To Map Their Marine Renewable Resources

Cargo ship leaking oil in Norway's only marine reserve

DEMOCRACY
Thawing permafrost may speed global warming: study

VIMS Team Glides Into Polar Research

Polar Bear Births Could Plummet With Climate Change

Volcanic vents found in Antarctic waters

DEMOCRACY
World Phosphorus Use Crosses Critical Threshold

Potatoes to be kept in 'doomsday' vault

Controversial Swedish wolf hunt ends, one escapes

China rice laced with heavy metals: report

DEMOCRACY
Philippine quake frightens resort city

Australia cyclone weakens after hitting Darwin

Study: Foreshocks might give quake warning

Increased flooding driven by climate change: study

DEMOCRACY
Somalia: Jihadists, regime eye big pushes

Chinese firm signs $1.2bn Khartoum airport deal

South Sudan: Born under a bad sign?

Tunisian army patrols ports to stop migrant exodus

DEMOCRACY
Living Fast But Dying Older Is Possible; If You're A Sheep

Chemical is found to block hair loss

Mind-moved bionic arm goes on display in US

Mathematical Model Explains How Complex Societies Emerge And Collapse


The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement