. Earth Science News .
Outside View: Reality, not rhetoric

Photo courtesy AFP.
by Harlan Ullman
Washington, April 21, 2009
For all except those on the extreme right and left of the political spectrum, the rhetoric of U.S. President Barack Obama has been impressive. The president has been painting a "kinder and gentler" view of American policy, in stark contrast to his predecessor. That said, actions dominate. Rhetoric is always trumped by reality and overtaken by surprise.

Beyond the missile and nuclear-science projects of North Korea that could provoke another crisis in East Asia, what surprises might stress test the Obama rhetoric over the coming months? Consider three possibilities: the economic and financial collapse of Russia, an Israeli decision to strike Iran's nuclear facilities and a de facto partition of Pakistan should extremist plots gain traction.

Russia is clearly in economic distress. While it has upward of $300 billion or $400 billion in reserves, this summer preset prices for Russian natural gas will be less than the costs of production. In essence, Russia will underwrite European energy needs -- an ironic twist given the sensitivity of European capitals to Moscow's use of the energy tool to leverage policy. When falling energy revenues force depletion of these precious dollar reserves and put even greater downward pressure on an already weak economy, compression or even economic collapse is not out of the question.

With Iran, Obama has signaled a willingness to improve relations. Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has responded positively, raising expectations that diplomacy and discussion might keep Iran's nuclear programs limited to peaceful use. Such an arrangement will not sit well with the new government in Israel, which is fearful if not paranoid about Iran and worried that negotiations will take time during which Iran will develop a real nuclear weapon.

Israel could finally conclude that Iran can never be trusted not to develop and possibly use nuclear weapons in its zeal to destroy the Zionist state. As either a strategic ploy to manipulate U.S. policy toward Iran or a threat to be carried out, an Israeli attack against Tehran's nuclear capabilities would be a nightmare scenario. Whether Israel has the capability for anything more than a symbolic strike is not the issue. Even a handful of cruise missiles or iron bombs falling on Iran would put the region on a footing tinged with catastrophe.

Perhaps the mother of all nightmare scenarios is Pakistan falling under the thrall of a Taliban or other extremist regime. Clearly and tragically, the insurgencies in Pakistan are growing in size and in geographic reach. Given the alternatives, Pakistani President Asif Zardari had little choice except to sign off on the Swat agreement to permit Shariah law to provide justice. No serious student of Pakistan can be happy with this decision. Unfortunately, the other options of redeploying the army or using force would have likely produced even worse results. Similarly, release from house arrest of the so-called Red Mosque cleric was an attempt to mollify public anger.

That said, the Taliban and al-Qaida associates have been turning poor farmers against the rich landowners as a means to provoke violence and ultimately to take power -- lessons from Lenin and Mao. A majority of Pakistanis are already pro-Islamist, anti-American, anti-Indian and conservative. Hence, unless the government can quickly step up economic reforms -- a further stress on an already cash-strapped exchequer -- and adopt a more effective counterinsurgency strategy, a de facto partition of Pakistan, or worse, greater levels of violence and even revolution become increasingly likely. South Asia in flames would be to international politics and regional stability what the American International Group and Lehman Brothers were to the financial meltdown.

Such contingencies are the basis for a great deal of effort within our national-security apparatus in the form of war games, planning and exercises. Yet the Obama administration is already awash in current crises from a still-failing economy to wars in Iraq and Afghanistan that, for the moment, appear to be escalating again in violence. Why should it consider such contingencies given that time is one of its most precious and scarcest resources?

The unsatisfactory answer is that any White House has no alternative except to examine what could be the more likely game changers -- those contingencies that will have profound consequences, good or bad, for the United States and its policies. And the only place that has the access for such consideration is within the National Security Council and its staff.

As the NSC evolves, having such a contingent authority becomes more essential. As the economic and financial crises struck with such a vengeance and now the relatively minor issue of Somali seaborne gangs vies for attention, we know we will be overloaded with crises and frequently surprised. We may not be able to prevent all future September 11ths. But we need to do far better in trying to anticipate them.

(Harlan Ullman is a senior adviser at the Atlantic Council. His last book was "America's Promise Restored: Preventing Culture, Crusade and Partisanship from Wrecking Our Nation.")

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
Democracy in the 21st century at TerraDaily.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Jackie Chan 'freedom' comments spark widespread ire
Hong Kong (AFP) April 21, 2009
The backlash over comments by Jackie Chan that Chinese people "need to be controlled" escalated Tuesday with everyone from academics to politicians censuring the Hong Kong film star.







  • Implementing Sustainable Technology To Monitor The Integrity Of Bridges
  • Australian wildfire inquiry told warning systems failed
  • How Day-Planner For Astronauts Helps Firefighters
  • Three in four quake homes habitable in a month: Berlusconi

  • Obama team urges climate change action in Congress
  • Climate bill to pass this year: House leader Pelosi
  • Britain outlines plans to cut carbon emissions by third
  • Oxfam predicts millions more victims of climate change

  • Satellites Show How Earth Moved During Italy Quake
  • RISAT2 Can See Through Thick Clouds
  • Satnav Reflection Technology For Remote Sensing Of The Earth
  • NASA Goddard Orders Second Instrument For GPM Mission

  • Russia, China finalise oil pipeline and supply deal: govt
  • Analysis: Caspian division inches forward
  • UC Davis Receives Renewable Energy Programs Grant
  • A Touch Of Potassium Yields Better Hydrogen-Storage Materials

  • Bird flu found in Tibet: state media
  • Economic crisis threatens AIDS fight: expert
  • First Broad Spectrum Anti-Microbial Paint To Kill Superbugs
  • Drug-resistant TB rampant in ex-USSR, China: study

  • The Life Histories Of The Earliest Land Animals
  • Feather Color Is More Than Skin Deep
  • China's wild alligators to double in 10 years: report
  • Rally against shark fin trade opens in Singapore

  • Vietnam PM halts controversial hotel in park: govt
  • Sofia mayor in 'garbage war' with Bulgaria PM
  • Bulgarian PM sets up emergency rubbish cell
  • Villa construction frenzy paving Bali paradise

  • Now Where Did I Leave My Car
  • Vegan, non-vegetarian bone density same
  • African pygmy genetics are traced
  • Is There A Seat Of Wisdom In The Brain

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement