. Earth Science News .
Rotting Body Row As India Mourns Missing Vultures

Indian vultures (pictured) have suffered the biggest decline of any animal species in the world, from millions in India to just a few thousand in little more than a decade, according to the Bombay Natural History Society.
by Paul Peachey
Mumbai (AFP) Sep 02, 2006
An Indian woman has ignited a furious row over the centuries-old tradition of using vultures to dispose of the dead by sending gruesome pictures of rotting corpses to hundreds of homes. About three bodies a day from the dwindling Parsi community in India are left to be stripped clean at a private 45-acre (18-hectare) complex in Mumbai but the practice is threatened by a dramatic decline in vulture numbers.

The issue erupted after scenes from inside the Towers of Silence were revealed by Dhun Baria, 65, who printed leaflets with grainy pictures of bodies and distributed them to 2,000 Parsi homes in Mumbai.

She said she only learned what happened behind the walls of the squat circular towers after her mother's body was taken when she died eight months ago.

"The staff told me everything. They said: 'Madam, it's a hell inside'," she said.

"I was crying a whole day and a night. It's the biggest mistake of my life that I have put my mother inside there. I thought I must help to change this system."

The Towers of Silence are off limits to all save pall bearers and the vultures who once circled overhead in large numbers before they dramatically died off.

Pictures circulating within the community are understood to show several dozen bloated and blackened bodies arranged around the upper platform of a tower and decomposing bones of other bodies in a well 20 feet (about six meters) below.

The process, known as Dakhma, dates back to ancient Iran where earth, water and fire were considered sacred and not to be polluted by the bodies of the dead.

Bodies were first put on top of mountains and later on to specially-built towers. It is not practised by Parsi migrants in other countries.

But the process that once took a few hours or days now takes months, according to reformers, with crows and snakes taking over from vultures.

They complain solar panels set up to aid decomposition have failed to speed up the process.

Baria said she was sent pictures anonymously and received threatening telephone calls over her campaign to persuade senior figures to allow cremation or burial.

Her actions have horrified the orthodox wing of the community which condemned her for making public a sacred place for the Parsis, part of the 3,500-year-old Zoroastrian religion.

"It's not going to be a big garden of roses inside," said Anahita Desai of the orthodox World Alliance of Parsi Irani Zarthoshtis. "But we feel she's exaggerating the situation."

The Indian Parsi community fled persecution in Iran to the west coast of India in the 10th century and prospered during the period of British colonial rule. They are among Mumbai's wealthiest groups.

Emigration and a tradition of marriage within the community has seen numbers fall below 70,000 across the country. Two thirds are in Mumbai.

But the Parsis' troubles are minor compared to the vultures that have suffered the biggest decline of any animal species in the world, from millions in India to just a few thousand in little more than a decade, according to the Bombay Natural History Society.

Its decline is blamed on the widespread use of now-banned painkiller Diclofenac for cattle that proves fatal to vultures feeding on carcasses.

The drug was banned in May this year but was too late for vultures in Mumbai with none left in the city.

The decline has led to continuing debate over how India's Parsi community should dispose of bodies.

Vispy Wadia, part of the reforming Association for Revival of Zoroastrianism, said people should also have the right to chose to be cremated or buried.

But some community leaders were resisting the move and want a vulture breeding programme to solve the problem.

Minoo Shroff, head of the Bombay Parsi Punchayat that runs the Towers of Silence, said: "The bulk of the community is very much for the system that has thrived for hundreds of years."

Source: Agence France-Presse

Related Links
Darwin Today At TerraDaily.com

Evolution Science Back On US Grant List
Washington DC (UPI) Sep 01, 2006
The U.S. Department of Education has reinstated evolutionary biology to a federal grant list for undergraduate studies. David Dunn -- acting under secretary and chief of staff to U.S. Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings -- said the omission, which had sparked heated protests from academics and evolution supporters, was accidental, New Scientist reported Thursday.







  • China To Build Earthquake Warning System At Three Gorges Reservoir Area
  • Interview: Katrina Lessons Learned
  • Katrina Response A 'Systemic Failure': Former US Emergency Response Chief
  • Engineers Find New Way To Close Levees

  • Evolution of Old World Fruit Flies on Three Continents Mirrors Climate Change
  • Iron Critical To Ocean Productivity And Carbon Uptake
  • Prevention Vital Against Desertification
  • More Carbon Dioxide May Help Some Trees Weather Ice Storms

  • Renewed Volcanic Activity At The Phlegrean Fields Tracked By Envisat
  • China To Launch 1st Environment Monitoring Satellite
  • NG Demonstrates Synthetic Aperture Laser Radar for Tactical Imagery
  • MODIS Images Western Wildfires

  • Protesters Aim To Shut Down British Power Station
  • Schwarzenegger Caps Greenhouse-Gas Emissions In California
  • Crude Oil Rebounds On Iran Jitters
  • Turning Fuel Ethanol Into Beverage Alcohol

  • Viruses Can Jump Between Primates And Humans
  • Is The Cure In The Blood For Bird Flu
  • HIV Life Expectancy Now Normal
  • Analysis: Time To Quit On AIDS Vaccine

  • Evolution Science Back On US Grant List
  • Rotting Body Row As India Mourns Missing Vultures
  • Kenyan Rangers Kill Rogue Jumbos After Fatal Human Attacks
  • NASA Study Solves Ocean Plant Mystery

  • Tonnes Of Pilgrimage Trash Threaten Indian Kashmir
  • Residents Flee Toxic Chemicals As Japan Finds Sunken Oil Tanker
  • Early-Warning Water Security System To Be Tested
  • China Making Little Progress On Pollution: Legislature

  • Snakes Credited For Our Keen Vision
  • Ancient Raptors Likely Feasted On Early Man
  • Remote Island Provides Clues On Population Growth, Environmental Degradation
  • Human Brain Filing System Uncovered

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement