Earth Science News
CLIMATE SCIENCE
Top science editor defends peer-review system in climate row
Top science editor defends peer-review system in climate row
By Roland LLOYD PARRY
Paris (AFP) Sept 15, 2023

Top science journal Nature was hit with claims last week that its editors -- and those of other leading titles -- have a bias towards papers highlighting negative climate change effects. It denies the allegation.

Scientist Patrick Brown shocked his peers when he said he had tailored his study on California wildfires to emphasise global warming. He claimed it would not have been accepted if it had not pandered to editors' preferred climate "narrative".

Nature's editor-in-chief Magdalena Skipper spoke to AFP about the case and the broader challenges facing academic publishing in the age of climate change and artificial intelligence.

The interview has been edited for length and flow.

- Bias claim -

Q. Are journal editors biased towards studies that emphasise the role of climate change over other factors?

A. "The allegation that the only reason why (Patrick Brown) got the paper published in Nature was because he chose the results to fit a specific narrative makes no sense at all. I'm completely baffled (by the claim). If a researcher provides compelling, convincing, robust evidence that goes against a consensus, that study actually becomes of special interest to us -- that's how science progresses.

"Since (climate change) is a pressing issue, of course there is an awful lot of research that is funded, performed and subsequently published to probe the matter, to understand how grave the problem really is today.

"In this case we had (peer-) reviewers saying that climate change is not the only factor that affects wildfires. The author himself argued that, for the purpose of this paper, he wished to retain the focus solely on climate change.

"We were persuaded that a paper with that focus was of value to the research community because of the contribution made by the quantification (of climate impacts)."

- Studies retracted -

Q. Research shows thousands of published studies across the academic world get retracted due to irregularities. Is the peer-review system fit for purpose?

A. "I think everyone in the scientific community would agree that the peer review system isn't perfect, but it's the best system we have. No system is 100-percent perfect, which is why at Nature, we have been trialling different approaches to peer review. There can be many rounds of peer review. Its complexity depends on the comments of the reviewers. We may decide not to pursue the paper.

"We have had cases at Nature of deliberate scientific misconduct, where somebody manipulates or fabricates data. It happens across disciplines, across scientific publishing. This is extremely rare.

"I think the fact that we see retractions is actually a signal that a system works."

- Pressure to publish -

Q. Is there too much pressure on scientists to get published at any cost?

A. "Science funding is precious and scarce, let's face it. Researchers have to compete for funding. Once an investigation has been funded and carried out, it makes sense for the results to be published.

"On the other hand, PhD students in many educational systems are required to publish one or more scientific papers before they graduate. Is this a helpful requirement when we know that a large proportion of PhD students are not going to continue in research?

"In many cases, early-career researchers waste time, opportunity and money to publish in predatory journals (that, unlike Nature, take a fee without offering proper peer review and editing), where their reputation suffers. They are effectively tricked into thinking that they are genuinely publishing to share information with the community."

- AI in publishing -

Q. What measures is Nature taking to monitor the use of artificial intelligence programs in producing scientific studies?

A. "We do not disallow using LLMs (large-language models such as ChatGPT) as a tool in preparation of manuscripts. We certainly disallow the use of LLMs as co-authors. We want the authors who have availed themselves of some AI tool in the process to be very clear about it. We have published and continue to publish papers where AI was used in the research process.

"I've heard of journals which published papers where leftover text from (AI tool) prompts was included in papers. At Nature, this would be spotted by the editors. But when we work with the research community and the authors who submit to us, there is an element of trust. If we find that this trust has been abused consistently then we may have to resort to some systematic way of scanning for generative AI use."

Q. Do editors have the technical means to scan for use of these AI tools?

A. At the moment, not to my knowledge. It's an incredibly fast-moving field. These generative AI tools are themselves evolving. There are also some really promising applications of AI in accelerating research itself.

Related Links
Climate Science News - Modeling, Mitigation Adaptation

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
CLIMATE SCIENCE
US envoy Kerry hopes China and US can 'come together' on climate
Nairobi (AFP) Sept 5, 2023
US climate envoy John Kerry said Tuesday that he hoped Washington and Beijing "could come together" in the fight against global warming, at a landmark summit in Kenya aimed at promoting Africa's potential as a green powerhouse. "I do hope that China and the United States, the two largest economies in the world, the two largest emitters in the world, I hope we could come together" on the issue of climate change, Kerry told reporters. "Our hope is that climate will be recognised for what it is. ... read more

CLIMATE SCIENCE
Disasters getting worse, say Brazil cyclone victims as Morocco quake leaves mental scars

Aid tents offer warning of Morocco quake survivor's future

Macron says no debate on French aid as toll soars to 10,000 in Morocco flood

As climate catastrophes rise, reinsurers reduce risks

CLIMATE SCIENCE
China pledges to invest billions in Serbian copper and gold mine

German circus replaces live animals with holograms

GomSpace receives order from EPIC Aerospace to support space tug development

From art squat to Berlin gentrification lightning rod

CLIMATE SCIENCE
'We're going to sink': Hundreds abandon Caribbean island home

Palestinian water woes highlight dashed hopes of Oslo Accords

Small islands take ocean protection case to UN court

Ethiopia says completes filling of Nile Renaissance mega-dam

CLIMATE SCIENCE
Cruise ship runs aground in Greenland fjord, no injured

New research explains "Atlantification" of the Arctic Ocean

Measuring the retreat of Italy's largest glacier

Study quantifies link between greenhouse gases, polar bear survival

CLIMATE SCIENCE
Meat, milk alternatives could slash food system emissions a third: study

Rice price spike offers preview of climate food disruption

France goes (a bit) veggie for Olympics

Satellites detect where locust infestations begin

CLIMATE SCIENCE
Derna counts the cost of Libya flood disaster

Race against time to find survivors 4 days after Morocco quake

Last-ditch hunt for Morocco quake survivors

Hawaii's Kilauea volcano erupts again

CLIMATE SCIENCE
'Finished here': A village vanishes in Morocco's quake

Debt-ridden Zambia's leader to visit top creditor China

Debt-ridden Zambia's leader to visit top creditor China

Tourists 'not going to let quake' stop Morocco trip

CLIMATE SCIENCE
Hong Kong's top court rules to recognise same-sex partnerships

New ancient ape from Turkiye challenges the story of human origins

ALS patient pioneering brain-computer connection

The race to link our brains to computers is hotting up

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.