. Earth Science News .
Indonesia 'Mud Volcano' Suit Alleges Human Rights Violated

Drilling by PT Lapindo Brantas pierced an underground chamber of hydrogen sulphide, forcing hot mud to the surface. The toxic sludge then swamped an area of 440 hectares (1,087 acres). The hearing into the case will resume next week. Another Indonesian watchdog has filed a separate suit against the same defendants alleging environmental damage from the mudflow, but it has yet to be given the court's green light. Photo courtesy AFP.
by Staff Writers
Jakarta (AFP) March 05, 2007
A court in Indonesia gave the go-ahead Monday for a lawsuit against the president and other officials for human rights violations over the slow response to a disastrous "mud volcano." The lawsuit, which also names the firm held responsible for triggering the toxic mudflow, alleges the tardy response breached human rights because it contributed to loss of life and impoverished the local population.

The steaming sludge swamped entire villages in Sidoarjo, near Indonesia's second largest city of Surabaya, displacing 15,000 people last year. Workers are still struggling to staunch the flow, which could continue for years.

Some 13 people died when a gas pipeline burst following subsidence blamed on the mud eruption.

Judges assessed the lawsuit and ruled it qualified to be heard, said a lawyer for the Indonesian Consumer Protection Foundation, which is behind the move.

"This is a welcome ruling. It sets a new precedent that the legal standing of suits filed by organisations or groups ... can now also cover human rights violations," the lawyer, Taufik Basari, told AFP.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono issued a decree establishing a team to tackle the mudflow some 102 days after the first eruption, Basari pointed out.

The lawsuit also names PT Lapindo Brantas, whose exploratory gas drilling in May 2006 is blamed for causing the mud to ooze to the surface. The government has ordered it to foot the compensation bill.

Drilling by PT Lapindo Brantas pierced an underground chamber of hydrogen sulphide, forcing hot mud to the surface. The toxic sludge then swamped an area of 440 hectares (1,087 acres).

The hearing into the case will resume next week. Another Indonesian watchdog has filed a separate suit against the same defendants alleging environmental damage from the mudflow, but it has yet to be given the court's green light.

The attempt to plug the crater, divert steaming mud to the sea and hold some back behind dykes is set to cost the government 3.4 trillion rupiah (371 million dollars), Public Works Minister Joko Kirmanto said earlier Monday.

The separate bill for compensating the victims of the disaster stood at 4.2 trillion rupiah, he said, according to a report from the detikFinance news website.

PT Lapindo Brantas has said it can pay only 3.5 trillion rupiah, leaving a compensation gap that has yet to be filled.

A team trying to plug the oozing crater with chains of heavy concrete balls said it had dropped 108 chains into the 50-metre (165-feet) mud hole up to Sunday, from an initial target of 375.

The audacious plan, devised by a local expert, aims to slow the flow by 50-70 percent, but some experts are sceptical about its chances of success and others worry it could cause new fissures.

Satria Bijaksana, a team expert, said so far "no noticeable changes have been monitored on the surface."

The chains have fallen deeper than expected into the crater, raising the prospect that many more than the 375 planned will be needed to staunch the flow.

Source: Agence France-Presse

Email This Article

Related Links
When the Earth Quakes

Hurricane Can Form New Eyewall And Change Intensity Rapidly
Seattle WA (SPX) Mar 05, 2007
Hurricanes can gain or lose intensity with startling quickness, a phenomenon never more obvious than during the historic 2005 hurricane season that spawned the remarkably destructive Katrina and Rita. Researchers flew through Rita, Katrina and other 2005 storms trying to unlock the key to intensity changes. Now, data from Rita is providing the first documented evidence that such intensity changes can be caused by clouds outside the wall of a hurricane's eye coming together to form a new eyewall.







  • Indian Army Airlifts Thousands Stranded On Kashmir Highway
  • Conflicting Signals Can Confuse Rescue Robots
  • Agreement Between ESA And The European Maritime Safety Agency Signed Today
  • Rescue Teams Scramble To Help Indonesia Landslide Victims

  • Wet Desert Of India Drying Out
  • The U.N.'s War On Global Warming
  • A Roadmap For Climate Change
  • Heatwave On The Top Of The World

  • Satellite Scientists Set To Descend On Hobart
  • CSIRO Imagery Shows Outer Great Barrier Reef At Risk From River Plumes
  • Scientists Gear Up For Envisat 2007 Symposium
  • ITT Passes Critical Design Review for GOES-R Advanced Baseline Imager

  • Iran Seeks Closer Naval Ties With Oil-Starved India
  • Wen Says China Must Stop Wasting Energy
  • Fats Into Jet Fuel: NC State Develops Biofuels Technology
  • Genome Sequencing Reveals A Key To Viable Ethanol Production

  • Two Weapons Ready For AIDS Fight
  • Troubling Trends In AIDS Cases
  • Resistant TB Spreads In Africa
  • E. Coli Bacteria Migrating Between Humans And Chimps In Ugandan Park

  • Fish, Trees, Cuddly Mammal Up For Protection From Human Trade
  • Scientists Invent Real-Life Tricorder For Chemical Analysis
  • A Year Of African Carnage From 23,000 Elephants
  • Researchers Review Bio Detection Technologies

  • Asian Pollution Linked To Stronger Pacific Storm System
  • As An Economy Blossoms An Ancient Capital Suffocates
  • Canada's Oil Sands To Keep Polluting
  • UN Forum Makes Limited Progress On Mercury Emissions

  • Time For TV Detox
  • DNA Study Explains Unique Diversity Among Melanesians
  • First Direct Electric Link Between Neurons And Light-Sensitive Nanoparticle Films Created
  • Eating Ice Cream May Help Women To Conceive But Low-Fat Dairy Foods May Increase Infertility Risk

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement